Everyone knows the benefits and advantages of traditional martial arts like Karate-do,
Boxing, Muay Thai,
Shaolin Kung Fu,
Jeet Kune Do, Kalarippayattu,
Taekwond, Judo, Aikido,
Jiu Jitsu, Wrestling etc. In a sports ring, any expert who has invested years of experience in such martial arts will be any day better than any novice. However, a common criticism of some traditional martial arts is the lack of real-life applicability – will all those fancy moves hold up against thugs with weapons on the street in a crowded bus. After a while, most people seem to realize that most Martial Arts in their traditional form are not realistic self-defence systems - and were never meant to be but a sport: involving rules to prevent illegal moves and foul play. Indeed there are some similarities between Krav-Maga and martial arts. However, Krav-Maga was developed in an environment where the Israeli military could not devote many hours to prolonged hand to hand combat training for their personnel.
Therefore, the Krav-Maga system was created with great importance placed on bringing students to a high level of skill in a relatively short period of time. There are no katas (forms) or rules in the system. Anything goes when you are fighting for your life!
Krav-Maga is more of a survival system dealing with personal safety issues in the context of defending against both armed and unarmed attackers. It is considered to be a modern, highly refined, street fighting system, designed to be utilized against muggings, street attacks, and sexual assaults.
| Traditional Martial Arts | Krav-Maga | | Formal, ritual oriented, and difficult to learn | Fighting dirty and learning no-holds-barred moves in a realistic environment | | Expects the student to adapt to it | Adapts to the student | | Teaches moves adapted from animals | Students build on their natural human reflexes | | Competitive tournaments, katas, rituals, or choreographed routines | Relies on “continuous motion" to complete the defence hence nothing is ritual or choreographed | | Brings students to a high level of skill in a long period like 10 to 20 years | Brings students to a high level of skill in a relatively short period | | Ritual oriented routines based on old era of swords and arrows | Incorporates modern realistic re-enactments so students learn how to operate under the stress | | As a sport, it has rules and illegal moves | No Rules; use everything you have | | Does not adapt or learn from other martial arts | Adapts and is a hybrid of mixed martial arts techniques like Boxing, Karate, Judo, JuJitsu, Muay Thai and other lesser known styles | | Most Martial Arts in their traditional form are not realistic Self Defence systems | Students learn to function during the stress and shock of a sudden, violent encounter/ Thus, it is excellent for realistic Self Defence in an unpredictable environment like streets |
|
|